All-American
 
NAIA First Team All-American
Elliott Jackson, 1973
Ed Tatum, 1974
Charlie Howard, 1981
Kelvin Blevins, 1984
Lyle Middleton, 1992
 
NAIA All-American Honorable Mention
Ryland Kieffer, 1997
Brandon Byrd, 2003
Norris Weintz, 2004 & 2006
Jonathan Donaldson, 2006

NAIA Scholar Athletes
Kevin Johnson, 1984 & 1985
Stefan Booy, 1999
John Akins, 2000
Kyle Hill, 2001 & 2002
Brandon Byrd, 2002 & 2003 & 2004
Jon David Parker, 2002, 2003 & 2004
Chris Wilkinson, 2005
Norris Weintz, 2005
Matt Owens, 2008
 
All-Region/All-District
 
First Team All-District 17
Elliott Jackson, 1973
Calvin Breedlove, 1974
Martin Jacobs, 1974
Ed Tatum, 1974
Clifton Avant, 1976 & 1978
Lee Andrew Smith, 1978 & 1979
Joe Holt, 1979 & 1980
Charlie Howard, 1981 & 1982
Rodney Tunson, 1981 & 1982
Kevin Johnson, 1983
Charlie Traub, 1988
Lyle Middleton, 1992
 
All-Southwest Region
Ryland Kieffer, 1996 & 1997
 
All-Conference
 
First Team All-TranSouth Conference
Jake Newton, 1998
Clint Reed, 1998 & 1999
John Akins, 2000
John Howell, 2000
Brandon Byrd, 2002 & 2003 & 2004
Norris Weintz, 2004 & 2005 & 2006
Jonathan Donaldson, 2006
 
Second Team All-TranSouth Conference
Thomas Rost, 2001
Billy Linson, 2001
Jason Donaldson, 2004
Dalun Smith, 2005
Levi Taylor, 2008
Andy Lee, 2009 & 2010